APEC economies and the APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC) are working on a practical problem for traders: most cross-border trade documents still move on paper. Two dialogues held in Dalian, China, in late August set out next steps on electronic trade documents and on customs procedures. Both feed into China’s host year, which builds to senior officials meeting in Shenzhen on November 14 and 15 and leaders on November 18 and 19.
The paper problem
The APEC Centre of Excellence for Paperless Trade (ACCEPT), a joint effort of APEC economies and ABAC that ministers endorsed in 2025, met to look at why digitalization has stalled. Figures cited by APEC put the number of paper trade documents in circulation at about four billion a year, with under 1% fully digitalized. Ocean carriers issue about 45 million bills of lading a year, and about 95% are not electronic.
Participants found that the main obstacle arises when electronic documents cross borders. Legal frameworks, technical standards and digital systems differ, so a document recognized in one economy may not be accepted in another. Kok Ping Soon, an ABAC Singapore member and chief executive of the Singapore Business Federation, which hosts the ACCEPT secretariat, said: “We want to reduce the cost and friction of moving goods across borders.”
The proposed approach starts with four documents: electronic bills of lading, certificates of origin, invoices and customs bonds. Pilots would test them in real transactions to identify remaining legal, technical and operational barriers. Denise Pereira of Singapore’s Ministry of Trade and Industry said: “The vision should be for successful pilots to provide a pathway towards regular commercial use.” ACCEPT will report progress each year to APEC economies and ABAC and is open to public and private participants.
Customs and the AI question
A separate APEC Customs-Business Dialogue, organized by the Sub-Committee on Customs Procedures, brought customs authorities and companies together in Dalian. Topics included moving border processes from paper to AI-enabled systems, electronic certification, electronic inspection and quarantine certificates for perishable food, and the treatment of low-value e-commerce shipments. Participants discussed how to balance faster clearance with revenue collection and consumer protection.
Sun Meijun, Minister of the General Administration of Customs of China, called for cooperation on “AI, big data and large-scale models.” APEC Secretariat Executive Director Eduardo Pedrosa said: “Customs administrations must continue evolving, not only as regulators, but as strategic partners.” The sub-committee is addressing customs chokepoints under the third phase of the APEC Supply Chain Connectivity Framework Action Plan.
What it means for business
For shippers, banks and logistics providers, the near-term opportunity is participation in pilots, which will shape the legal and technical standards later applied across the region. Companies handling cross-border e-commerce should follow the customs work on low-value shipments, where APEC economies are weighing clearance speed against revenue and consumer protection. The customs dialogue also pointed to Authorized Economic Operator programs and mutual recognition arrangements as ways to support smaller firms.















